White Paper – 5 Steps You Must Take to Prepare for the CCPA

Effective Jan. 1, 2020, the California Consumer Privacy Act creates new protections for the personal data of California residents and new requirements for the businesses that process it. With CCPA’s 12-month look back from the effective date, enforcement beginning July 2020, and a private right of action tied to data breaches, some critical action is needed now.   Go to the IAPP Site for full story and white paper:


Focusing on Privacy Won’t Solve Facebook’s Problems

At Facebook’s annual developer conference on April 30, founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg laid out a major change for the social media platform: a shift to privacy. Facebook’s redesign, which was first announced in a blog post in March, aims to prioritize private, encrypted messaging (on Facebook Messenger as well as Facebook-acquired WhatsApp and Instagram’s Direct Messaging) and Facebook groups over the more public “town square”-style News Feed that has been the cornerstone of the platform since its founding. Private messaging, Zuckerberg argued, is the future of social media communications.


Full Post: https://www.lawfareblog.com/focusing-privacy-wont-solve-facebooks-problems

China’s New Cybersecurity Program: NO Place to Hide

The Chinese government has been working for several years on a comprehensive Internet security/surveillance program.  This program is based on the Cybersecurity Law adopted on 2016. The plan is vast and includes a number of subsidiary laws and regulations. On December 1, 2018, the Chinese Ministry of Public Security announced it will finally roll-out the full plan.

Full Story: https://www.chinalawblog.com/2019/09/chinas-new-cybersecurity-program-no-place-to-hide.html

Is Ireland breaching EU rules by underfunding data regulator?

Complaint filed with European Commission over decision not to give more to watchdog

For a Government obsessed with the optics it is surprising how often this current administration does things that leave it wide open to criticism.

FULL STORY: https://www-irishtimes-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.irishtimes.com/business/technology/is-ireland-breaching-eu-rules-by-underfunding-data-regulator-1.4047897?mode=amp

Data on 92M Brazilians found for sale on underground forums

Several members-only dark web forums are reportedly auctioning what appears to be a stolen government database featuring the personal information of 92 million Brazilian citizens.

The 16GB SQL database contains such information as name, birth date, mother’s name, gender and tax details including taxpayer IDs, according to BleepingComputer, which credits the discovery to a researcher with the Twitter user name Breach Radar.


Check out this article at: https://www.scmagazine.com/home/security-news/data-breach/data-on-92m-brazilians-found-for-sale-on-underground-forums/

What is going on or not going on, The Need for Data Protection Preparedness

Woodcut by Tommaso Garzoni depicting a town crier with a trumpet

Data breaches that occurred over the last few months have quite literally impacted close to one-third of the US population. This staggering number supports the inevitable conclusion that something is very wrong, and that data vulnerabilities represent possibly one of the greatest threats facing not only corporate enterprise, but government agencies as well. Aetna, Equifax, and Time Warner Cable, companies that collectively manage the health information, credit ratings (including highly sensitive financial data), and the communications of a large percentage of the population, recently admitted to massive data breaches and notified those impacted customers that their personal information had been compromised. Reasons given vary from exploitation of a website vulnerability and an affiliate accidently leaking sensitive personal information. These companies will face not only potential litigation and regulatory enforcement action that could represent billions of dollars of loss. Equifax shares have dropped 21 percent since their breach was disclosed on Sept. 7, the biggest two-day drop since 1998. (https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-11/equifax-backed-out-of-public-investor-presentation-after-breach). Even more sobering, had these breaches occurred after May 25, 2018, the official start data for enforcement of the new EU General Data Protection Regulation, which at least in the case of Equifax also resulted in significant data loss for UK personal information, these companies could have faced additional staggering penalties of up to 4% of their global annual revenue.

These companies have demonstrated weakness in compiling, control, management and appropriate protection of this sensitive data. Identification of the systems that are being utilized and ongoing cohesive management of data is crucial for a structured preparedness to secure sensitive customer personal information. If you are questioning your preparedness and well you should, BeyData has the solution.
While a reactionary approach seems to be the norm these day, it is not effective. BeyData has developed BeyData Librarian a Unified Automated Risk Management System, that empowers organizations to take the responsible and proactive to build and maintain a catalog of all their data flows.
BeyData Librarian provides a secure enterprise system that allows organizations to indentify, assess, prioritize, remediate, mitigate and monitor risk across the organization. Its scalable, hybrid infrastructure provides a framework that allows you to build a catalog of assets, records, data flows, processes and people inside and outside the organization, to map the flow of data within and between these assets and automates the process of risk management.
Further it allows you to utilize our risk frameworks to complete and conduct Privacy and Data Protection Impact Assessments, as well as Security and Risk Impact Assessments.
Companies and organizations must better identify risks in advance of a threat, so that they can mitigate those risks, instead of reacting to them once breached. Why suffer the damage to reputation and customer confidence and expose your company to liability and costs because of inaction?
Contact us if you would like to learn how Bey Data’s Automated Unified Risk Management System can address your Privacy and Data needs.
Ponemon Institute, 2017 Cost of Data Breach Survey – Do not have to register to download

Director’s Corner: Which Edition of BeyData Librarian is right for you?

As the Director of Sales I am often asked a basic question, “Which edition of BeyData Librarian is right for me?”   This is a good question and one that people should consider based on their mission.    The different editions were purpose built for specific needs and therefore the wrong edition could lead to a waste of resources or not having what you need.

To understand this better let us first look at a couple of early product roles:

  • Create Assessments
  • Run and Use Assessments

So, on many teams an assessment may be created by a law firm or consultant. These then would be given to their client.  If you are never going to run an assessment except to test if it functions as designed than the personal edition is right for you.  It is in the running of the assessments themselves where you will see a difference.

Let us ask some Questions and show the version for each answer in a grid:

Who will be using the software?

Answer Personal Professional Enterprise
It will be a single user on their personal computer Best Choice Not Required Not Required
There will be three users of the software in one location Will not work Best Choice Would work, may be overkill
There will be many users across our organization in multiple locations Will not Work Not the Best Choice Best Choice


Report Customization?

Answer Personal Professional Enterprise
Reports do not need customization Best Choice Not Required Not Required
Need to customize all reports Will not work Will Work Will Work


User Access?

Answer Personal Professional Enterprise
Just me Best Choice Not Required Not Required
Need Windows Authentication Will not work Will Work Will Work
Need Active Directory Support Will not Work Will Work Will Work



Assessments and Diagrams?

Answer Personal Professional Enterprise
I only need to create Assessment Templates, Nothing else Best Choice Overkill Overkill
I need to create Assessments, Data Flow / UML Diagrams, and Run Assessments Will not work Will Work Will Work
I need to Run Assessments Will Work Will Work Will Work


The Personal Edition is good for those just starting out where the work being done is NOT team based.  Additionally, this version is great for a technical person that is building assessment templates but will not actually be completing any assessments.  It is also a good way to run a full fledge trial of the software with all functionality enabled.

The Professional Edition is often referred to as the Team Edition. Multi User support with SQL Express and Server Support along with support for multiple Authentication methods.  The Professional edition also adds the ability to customize the reporting to match your company and brand.

The Enterprise Edition has everything that the previous versions have but adds Azure support for the Hybridicity required by many organizations who also work with third parties and external organizations.


Automating your Assessment Process with BeyData Librarian

BeyData Librarian ships with many templates but you may need to create a company specific Assessment.  This may seem like a daunting task but it is quite simple. This blog post is designed to take you through the steps to automating a manual or spread sheet process that you currently use.  For this example, we will use the Cloud Accountability Projects, Data Protection Impact Assessment.  You can view the PDF here: Assessment PDF  and more information regarding the cloud accountability project can be found here: http://www.a4cloud.eu/ . This assessment is provided under creative Commons with an Attribution and ShareAlike requirement (https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/licensing-types-examples/).

What we want to do is replicate the “Cloud DPIA Questionnaire” from this document so that instances of the assessment can be run and rerun in an automated process. Here are the steps:


  1. Create a new Assessment: We will call the project CDPIA by Selecting the [ Add] button and then renaming the default new name of “Assessment Definition 1” to “CDPIA”

Assessment Manager


  1. Now let’s go ahead and Edit the New Assessment by Selecting the [Edit] button which brings up the assessment editor.Assessment Editor
  2. From here we can start adding blocks. To save time we have completed this assessment before writing the blog post.  For your information, this is a simple process of dropping blocks and connecting them.  Let us talk about block types used.


The Task Block is simple and can be identified by its shape of a rectangle. The first         one we have is EU Activities and more importantly it corresponds with the first         question in the assessmentQuestion and rules

So, in this first line there are some questions regarding the type of project and defining territory

First, “Is the establishment of your activities in European territory?”

Then there is an Explanation section for the Privacy Pro completing the Assessment: “Whether the processing of personal information of your undertaking takes place in the European Union or not is not relevant. If you are not established in European Union territory, but you offer goods or services to individuals in the EU or monitor them, then you should answer Y to this question.”


The type of question is a Yes/No and for our purposes we will turn this into a checkbox and Checked\Unchecked (Yes/No or True/False) as we will need to test this answer.

Here is what the Task block pages look like with descriptions:

The first page defines the task, you can have one or many.  There is the Task Subject /Question and then the description. There is of course the assignment and whether you want to send an email alert. The “Assessment Team” as shown here is a user group, you could also just send it to an individual.  Some people prefer not to use email updates as part of the workflow, this is not required.

Task Subject

The Assessment comes with Guidance related to the Response, in Column one the Response Yes is: You have to comply with European Union laws, and Response No is blank. The Actions for each item are important.

The status of this task can be an Open/Done value or the approval type.

Task Status

Some Privacy Pros will want to attach or review attachments for any instance of the assessment. This tab is where you define those items.


The Answers Page is where we define the items for which we want answers. It can be one to many items and how the answer is provided is up to you. In this case we want a check box but you can also use text, date time, memo, drop down choices.   In many cases in this assessment we will use both Check boxes and drop downs.



Finally, there is the task expiration page, and this can be set to whatever you require. The assessment that ships with BeyData Librarian by default ships with no expiration.

Expiration Page



The Actions are important and step one has the following actions:

If Yes: Go to the next question

If No: This Questionnaire is addressed to businesses and/or organisations which are established in the European Union. Since you are not established in the EU, this Questionnaire does not apply to you. (So Exit the Assessment)

You can see this clearly in the flowchart:

Flowchart Showing Flow to end


A “Yes” answer continues to the next step and a “No” answer ends the assessment.



The Score, Weight and Indicators need to be set on this first task block:

And for this first block it is: N/A – This answer is not counted in the overall score with a weight of zero and no risk indicators in this assessment they describe risk indicators as follows.

There are seven privacy indicators:

Sensitivity (SEN): Risks related to a sensitive market (i.e. elderly, children, etc.) and/or sensitive data (i.e. health or medical conditions, finance, sexual behavior)


Compliance (C): Risks related to compliance with external standards, policies, laws, etc.


Trans-border data flow (TB): Risks related to transfer of information across national borders


Transparency (T): Risks related to transparency in the areas of notice/user messaging and choice/consent


Data control (DC): Risks related to control of the data lifecycle (i.e., collection, usage, quality, and/or retention)


Security (SEC): Risks related to security of data and data flows


Data sharing (DS): Risks related to sharing data with third parties


  1. Now we have to decide programmatically what to do next, and we therefor put a decision block on the flowchart.Decision Block

And here we ask if we are collecting European data  and as required the answer “NO” ends the assessment and the answer “Yes” goes to the next step.


  1. Now we go on to line number two and question number two defines a checkbox question, “Do you handle information that can identify other people through one or more of the following activities?” With guidance, “Think for instance, if you use names, identification numbers or location data. The collection of information related to individuals can be potentially intrusive to the information privacy rights of these individuals. In some types of projects information provided is more sensitive than in other ones e.g. Financial data”. Regardless of the answer when complete we go to the next question.


  • Web Browsing
  • Account and/or Subscription Management
  • Authentication and Authorization
  • Customization
  • etc

We can handle both line two and three in this task block

Line Two

Line two and three description


What is different here is there are risk indicators that we must deal with

If “health, employment, social security and law enforcement” then 1, else if “historical, scientific statistical or research purposes” then 1/4, else if “exercise of the right to freedom of expression or information” then 3/4, else 0.  With a weight of 1 and code SEN, here is an example:


So, to set risk for this task we would select the [ Set Risk] button

Demo Risk

And under Risk to Individual set values as required.

PLEASE NOTE: You could also set these in the flowchart programmatically, please see the help file for more information on programmatic options.


  1. You repeat these steps as much as required, this assessment has 50 steps and branching based on conditions. And in the end the assessment looks like this in the assessment editor.Full Assessment in Editor


  1. Once created you need to test the Assessment and you do that by opening the assessment manager and selecting the [Run New] button and giving the test assessment a name and select [OK]BlogDemo Instance



Remember even if you are setting the risk programmatically you must create the risk table for the instance as this is where risk values are stored for the assessment. After selecting [OK] you will get a message that the assessment instance and risk table are created – Once the instance is created the assessment is running.






To create the BeyData Librarian Assessment took three (3) hours and to run a complete test of the assessment and branching took 17 minutes.   So in under 3.5 hours the assessment was created and new instances could be created at will.  If we had the original spreadsheet it would have been quicker because when copying and pasting from a PDF many formatting updates are needed. It would have been under two hours if we had the original content.

Running our Example

You can Update your software to the latest build, or request that your account representative send you the new assessment template and import the template via the share functionality


If you do not have the software and want to see this in operation simply request a demo.  https://www.beydata.com/RequestTrial.htm

Example Output

Example Output